Laboratori ya Roulette · Laboratori · Dipalopalo · metsotso e le 8

Botlhokwa jwa Dipalopalo

“Botlhokwa” bo kaya gore ga go a tlwaelega fa leotwana le siame, e seng “ga nnete” e bile e seng “go na le poelo”.

Karabo e khutshwane

P-value ya 0.05 e kaya gore leotwana le le siameng le ne le tla ntsha mokgwa o o sa lekalekaneng jaana gangwe mo go masome a mabedi. Fa lo leba maotwana a le masome a mabedi, le le lengwe le tla feta ka phoso.

tlwaelo
p < 0.05
kelo ya maduo a a fosagetseng
5% ka teko
kalafi
go boeletsa
se e seng sone
p(leotwana le a sekama)

P-value ke eng

Assuming the stated null model, the p-valuelaboratorip-valueKgonagalo ya go bona kgatogo e e kana ka e e bonweng kgotsa go feta fa leotwana le ne le siame.Bala yotlhe → is the probabilitydipaloKgonagaloTshono ya maduo, go tswa go 0 go ya go 1 kgotsa 0% go ya go 100%. Palo e le nngwe: 1/37 = 2.70%.Bala yotlhe → of a test statistic at least as extreme as the observed one. It is not the probability that the wheel is fair or that the result arose by chance. Interpretation also depends on the design, assumptions and tests attempted.

poleloe nepagetse?
p = 0.03 e kaya gore leotwana le le siameng le naya data e e feteletseng jaana 3% ya nakoee
p = 0.03 e kaya gore go na le kgonagalo ya 97% ya gore leotwana le a sekamannyaa
p = 0.03 e kaya gore phaposi e e mogote e tla sala e le mogotennyaa
p = 0.03 morago ga go sekaseka maotwana a le 30 ke bosupi jo bo nonofilengnnyaa; lo lebelela maduo a le mangwe kgotsa a mabedi a a ntseng jalo ka tshono
p = 0.03 gabedi, mo disampoleng tse pedi tse di ikemetseng go tswa mo leotwaneng le le tshwanangjaanong go tshwanetse go elwa tlhoko

Dipapiso tse dintsi

Teko nngwe le nngwe e lo e dirang mo leotwaneng le le siameng e na le kgonagalo ya 5% ya go feta ka selekanyo sa 5%. Lekang maotwana a le masome a mabedi mme le le lengwe le a feta. Lekang leotwana le le lengwe mo nakong di le masome a mabedi mme e le nngwe e a feta. Lekang sampole e le nngwe ka ditlhopha di le 37 tsa diphaposididirisiwaPhaposiNngwe ya diphaposi di le 37 tse di nang le dipalo mo rotor. Gape: slot, cup.Bala yotlhe →, ditlhopha di le thataro tsa dikarolo tsa leotwanaleotwanaKarolo ya leotwanaKgolokwe e e kopaneng ya diphaposi mo leotwaneng, e e farologanang le setlhopha mo thulaganyong ya dibete.Bala yotlhe → le ditlhopha di le tharo tsa mebala mme sengwe se a feta. Kalafi ke go swetsa teko pele ga go leba data, go e dira gangwe, le go netefatsa mo datang e ntšhwa. Go sekaseka mo go fitlhelang leotwana le le “sekamang” gantsi ke gone go ntshitseng maduo.

Kgonagalo ya bonnye maduo a le mangwe a a fosagetseng ka p < 0.05%
teko e le 1
5%
diteko di le 5
22.6%
diteko di le 10
40.1%
diteko di le 20
64.2%
diteko di le 37 (e le nngwe ka phaposi)
85.0%
%
042.5085.0%
1 − 0.95ⁿ. Go leka phaposi nngwe le nngwe ka nosi go batla go tlhomamisa gore go fitlhelwa e e “botlhokwa”.

Botlhokwa kgatlhanong le bogolo

A large sample can detect a small departure from fairness that still does not make a bet profitable. At a true pocket probability of 1/36.5, a 35:1 bet has negative expectation. At 1/36 it breaks even. A p-value does not measure the size or practical value of an effect.

Thata

Power is the chance of rejecting the null under a specified alternative. For one pocket chosen in advance, an exact one-sided 5% binomial test on 1,000 spins rejects at 37 or more hits. If the true rate is 1/30, its power is about 28%, not 50%.

Tekanyetso ya tiriso

Gore polelo ya tshekamo e kgatlhise: teko e e tlhophilweng pele, p < 0.01 go na le 0.05, go boeletsa mo sampoleng e e ikemetseng ya bogolo jo bo tshwanang, le kelo e e akanyeditsweng ya go tshwaya mo diphaposing tse di ratiwang ya 1/34 kgotsa go feta morago ga go boeletsa. Tekanyetso eo e fitlheletswe ga le mmalwa fela mo hisitoring ya motshameko mme ga e ise e ko e fitlhelelwe, go ya ka fa dirikoto tsa setšhaba di bontshang, mo leotwaneng la segompieno le le tlhokometsweng.

Dipotso

Goreng 0.05?

Tlwaelo go tloga mo dingwageng tsa bo1920. Ga go na sepe se se kgethegileng ka yone; 0.01 ke moedi o o utlwalang go feta fa lo sekaseka maotwana a mantsi.

Fa p e le nnye thata, a leotwana ka nnete le a sekama?

Gongwe ga le ntshe maduo a a lekalekaneng. E ka nna ama ya moabi, phoso ya go kwala kgotsa bothata jwa go tsenya data. Boeletsang.

A maduo a a botlhokwa a mpolelela gore ke bee mo phaposing efe?

No. That requires a separate estimate of hit probability, its uncertainty and the actual payoutmadiTueloSe bete e e fentseng e se busang, se se bolelwang jaaka “X go 1” mo godimo ga peeletso e e busediwang.Bala yotlhe →.

Monate wa Dipalo

Ntlha lekang tseno ka bo lona. Tharabololo nngwe le nngwe e phuthilwe; e buleng fa lo ipaakanyeditse.

  1. Suppose a dozenbeteDozen1–12, 13–24 kgotsa 25–36, e duela 2:1.Bala yotlhe → chosen before data collection appears 742 times in 3,000 independent double-zeroleotwanaLefelaPhaposi e le nngwe e tala e go seng bete ya tekatekano, ya dozen kgotsa ya kholomo e e e khupetsang; motswedi wa molemo wa khasino. Gape: lefela le le lengwe, 0.Bala yotlhe → spins. Under the uniform model, how many standard deviationsdipaloPharologano ya motheoModi wa sekwere wa pharologano; sekgala sa tlwaelo sa maduo go tswa mo boleng jo bo lebeletsweng.Bala yotlhe → below the mean is that? What is the probabilitydipaloKgonagaloTshono ya maduo, go tswa go 0 go ya go 1 kgotsa 0% go ya go 100%. Palo e le nngwe: 1/37 = 2.70%.Bala yotlhe → of 742 or fewer hits?

    Bontsha tharabololo

    Karabo Dipharologano tsa motheo di ka nna 8.1 kwa tlase. Leotwana le le siameng le ne le tla dira jalo gangwe mo maitekong a ka nna 3 × 10¹⁵, e leng le ka motlha. Karabo e e phasaladitsweng le potso e re 11.75; rona re bona 8.07.

    Under the stated model, X is binomial with n = 3,000 and p = 12/38. Its mean is np ≈ 947.37 and its standard deviation is √(np(1 − p)) ≈ 25.46.

    The standardized difference is (742 − 947.37)/25.46 ≈ −8.07. Summing the exact binomial probabilities from 0 through 742 gives P(X ≤ 742) ≈ 9.77 × 10⁻¹⁷. A normal approximation with continuity correction gives about 4.25 × 10⁻¹⁶; the relative error is large this far into the tail.

    This is the probability of the specified data event under the model, not the probability that the wheel is fair. Such a result calls for checking the observations, independence, uniformity and analysis plan. Selecting the worst-looking dozen after inspecting data, or searching many wheels or time periods, requires accounting for that selection.

Metlae ya go iketla

Leotwana le le lengwe mo go a le masome a mabedi a a siameng le “botlhokwa”. Ke se palo e se kayang.

Leotwana le le lengwe mo go a le masome a mabedi a a siameng le “botlhokwa”. Ke se palo e se kayang.

Metswedi

  1. Pearson, K. “On the criterion that a given system of deviations from the probable…” https://www.amstat.org/asa/files/pdfs/P-ValueStatement.pdf
  2. Feller, W. An Introduction to Probability Theory and Its Applications, Vol. 1. https://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/software/dataplot/refman1/auxillar/chsqgood.htm
sekao: ya Yuropa, lefela le le lengwemokgwa wa tiro ↗metswedi ↗